Our Publications

Our Publications

Rethinking the Test Pile

A National Study of K-8 Assessments

Rethinking the Test Pile is a national study by Education First examining how academic assessment systems are evolving across states and districts. The research includes a national study of K–8 district assessment practices, a scan of state policies shaping local assessment architecture and a review of past assessment audit and literacy efforts.

We examined what academic assessments students take and why, how much time and money they require, how leaders decide what to administer and how state policy choices shape local systems. We catalogued assessments across 67 districts in 38 states, interviewed district and state leaders, analyzed assessment statutes and guidance across 27 states and reviewed past audit and assessment literacy initiatives.

Taken together, the analyses across 42 states point to a clear conclusion: Local assessment systems have become crowded, overlapping and difficult to manage, often growing through compliance rather than intentional design. Bringing coherence to these systems requires intentional choices about purpose, alignment and use across the full assessment ecosystem.

In This Report

  • Executive Summary: A brief overview of the most consistent patterns emerging across states and districts. This synthesis highlights the core challenges shaping today’s assessment landscape and introduces the major themes and recommendations explored across the full set of reports.
  • National K—8 Academic Assessments Scan: This report examines how layered requirements and local decision-making shape assessment systems in districts and schools. Drawing on national research and district leader insights, we explore how assessment practices are experienced across the country and where opportunities exist to improve coherence and clarity.
  • Scan of State Assessment Policies: This report analyzes how state policy efforts are influencing local assessment design and implementation. It highlights areas of divergence across states, emerging policy trends and potential opportunities to improve coherence and clarity.
  • State Assessment Audit and Assessment Literacy Efforts: This companion report reviews current and past state efforts to address assessment volume and improve assessment literacy. It surfaces lessons from audit initiatives, decluttering efforts and strategies aimed at helping systems make more intentional assessment decisions.

Read the full reports—and sign up to stay updated on this research—below.

ADA Request Form
Sign me up
By signing up, you agree to receive occasional communications from Education First. You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Statement

Meet the experts who authored this publication

Khaled Ismail
Khaled Ismail
Principal Consultant
Yeonjae Lee
Yeonjae Lee
Senior Consultant
Kelly_Jasiura
Kelly Jasiura
Consultant
headshot
Olivia Kelly
Associate Consultant
Jenn Vranek professional headshot
Jenn Vranek
Founding Partner